• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram
  • GoodReads
  • BookBub
 Newsletter Sign-Up

I Shall Not Steal

This is a resolution I wish many readers would take in 2010. Let me explain why. It was with some excitement that on December 29th I saw my book go on sale, but not a few hours after its official release, I got this from Google Alerts:

Astatalk – How I Met My Countess — Boyle, Elizabeth download request
Romantic Fiction → How I Met My Countess — Boyle, Elizabeth. 29 Dec 2009, 15: 36. Download. Sponsored 50 MBit/sec direct download. Does anyone have this? …

Yes, here was a reader asking for an illegal copy of How I Met My Countess. Damn, girl, Barnes & Noble wasn’t open yet, so you have to steal a copy? Come on!

I really wanted to meet the reader who posted this on one of the myriad of download boards and ask her this: Would you go into Walmart, put a copy of the book in your purse and walk out with it? And when she said (and probably emphatically and in an insulted tone) “No!” and I would have to follow that up with a “Why not?” and the answer is obvious: Because that’s stealing.

When I worked in software piracy, I heard all the excuses about why we should all look the other way on electronic theft–it doesn’t hurt anyone, it’s just one copy. First of all, electronic theft hurts everyone. And it is never just one copy. It may seem like thin air to the myriad of thieves out there, but they are no better than the Mob–you are robbing companies and authors of their legitimate revenue and worse, you are robbing yourself. Because legitimate revenue is taxed: B&O taxes, personal taxes, corporate taxes. Counterfeiting and electronic piracy account for one third of lost revenues in North America–everything from software, watches, purses, toothpaste and baby formula. One third. Think if that revenue was legitimately and fairly taxed? Think of the jobs that could be gained with that revenue. In the long run, we would all be richer with better roads, schools, and yes, health care.

And it isn’t just the authors and publishers who are robbed, it is everyone up and downstream in the life of a book: from the warehouse workers, to the artist, to the shippers who move books, bookstores and their employees, printers, box-makers, gads, even the tape that goes into closing the boxes, the list goes on and on. Because when the electronic book is stolen with impunity online, it cuts into legal and legitimate sales of the hard copy book, which is the lifeblood of this industry. And eventually those losses turn into layoffs, less offerings from booksellers, less bookstores, less books, less authors. Sound familiar? The people who think they are getting a free book are robbing themselves of what they love.

Here is the other argument that makes me shake my head with wonder at the ethics and upside down values that these online shoplifters and thieves use to convince themselves that they are in the right: I read too many books to afford them. Whaaaah? Does anyone else look at this and just shake your head. Do they feel the same about shoes and handbags and lattes that they need to consume gives them the right to steal their goodies from Nordstrom, Macys and Starbucks? I doubt it.

Here’s the simple solution: If you can’t afford the books, go to the library and check out your books for free. At least the library pays for their copy(ies). And if they don’t have the copy you want, I have yet to meet a librarian who wouldn’t track that book down for you and get it for you via inter-library loan. Again, for free. And here’s another question for the “i-can’t-afford-my-habit-so-I’ve-turned-to-crime” crowd: If you can’t afford your groceries do you steal them from the grocery store? Do you break into your neighbor’s house ’cause you’re out of beer or they have a dvd you’ve always wanted? No, of course not, so why are you stealing books?

DSCN1348_2Now I know that there are no arguments that will stop some people, but I want to add one last image that I ask you to hold in your heart: Tiny Tim. Every author out there has their own Tiny Tim–a mortgage to pay, kids to feed, an electric bill, medical bills and electronic piracy robs their ability to take care of their Tiny Tim, chipping away at his little broken crutch as sure as if Ebenezer Scrooge was standing there trying to make kindling out of it. My Tiny Tim is an eight year old boy with autism. His medical bills run 25k a year–and that’s the part our insurance won’t cover. So when you steal my books, upload them or download them, I want you to envision this child and the speech therapy ($100 per hour) and physical therapy ($85 per hour) that you are depriving him of. That’s my Tiny Tim and when you steal my books, that is who you are robbing of a legitimate chance at a good life.

So I would ask everyone who loves all these “free” books, to realize nothing in life is free, and eventually you are only stealing from yourself . . . and perhaps even this small child. Resolve in 2010 not to steal. Every author, composer, designer and creator on the planet will thank you by continuing to be creative.

20 comments to “I Shall Not Steal”

  1. Rachael
    January 27th, 2010 at 4:10 am · Link

    Lovely, timely, and SMART. Thank you for this.

  2. Julie
    January 27th, 2010 at 7:32 am · Link

    You go girl–nothing like the truth

  3. thea
    January 27th, 2010 at 8:45 am · Link

    i’m glad i didn’t know you could do this so i can continue never doing it! to be honest, i broke my hard drive by downloading a book that was FREE! so now i never bother. E, sorry you are the victim of such a thing.

  4. Julia Quinn
    January 27th, 2010 at 9:28 am · Link

    Thank you for posting this.


  5. Katharine Ashe
    January 27th, 2010 at 11:48 am · Link

    Well said, Elizabeth. Thank you!

  6. Maureen McGowan
    January 27th, 2010 at 1:58 pm · Link

    FABulous post, Elizabeth. So great to bring it down to the personal level, both in terms of you and the thieves (who think they aren’t thieves).

  7. Allison Brennan
    January 27th, 2010 at 2:52 pm · Link

    Brilliant, well-written, perfectly stated. Amen.

  8. Diane O.
    January 27th, 2010 at 5:09 pm · Link

    That’s why I buy them — even from my generous friends!

  9. Sasha Allgood
    January 27th, 2010 at 7:38 pm · Link

    Well done!

  10. Sarah MacLean
    January 30th, 2010 at 8:28 am · Link

    So well said, Elizabeth!

    I actually had this conversation with my husband last night…and the thing that KILLS me is this: If people want books for free, they can have them. They just have to go to the library. In fact, I endorse going to the library. I believe in the library system. Maybe if more people used the library system, it wouldn’t be struggling to survive.

    To you!

  11. Peggy
    January 30th, 2010 at 9:30 am · Link

    Great Post! This applies to both books and music. I never have understood why anyone would not consider illegal downloads stealing.

  12. DOP_girl
    January 30th, 2010 at 10:04 am · Link

    I am a photographer and agree completely – digital images are stolen every day and posted on various blogs & websites. it’s all the same -using intellectual property without paying for it is stealing.

  13. Melissa G
    January 30th, 2010 at 10:06 am · Link

    What an awesome post. Hopefully it will make it to a few of the folks who think they are ‘entitled’ (somehow) to steal books electronically, and they will stop this selfish behavior.

  14. Sherilyn Winrose
    January 30th, 2010 at 10:34 am · Link

    Well stated Elizabeth.

    Anyone thinking of using ‘the rich author’ defense, that doesn’t fly either. Most of us make a pittance in comparison to the hours put into a single title.

  15. Fedora
    January 30th, 2010 at 10:46 am · Link

    Absolutely well said, Elizabeth! Thank you!

  16. Serena Robar
    January 30th, 2010 at 11:19 am · Link

    Amen! Brilliantly put E.

  17. Jana Orchard
    January 31st, 2010 at 3:02 pm · Link

    AMEN!!! From an AVID reader who probably goes through more books in a year than most people do in a life-time!! Wish you could get this kind of understanding through the entire world! God Bless!

  18. Tammy Cato
    January 31st, 2010 at 5:36 pm · Link

    Well said and you never know what virus you’re going to get with that free download.

  19. Charisma Knight
    February 4th, 2010 at 6:12 am · Link

    I enjoy splurging on my ebooks, even before I became an author. Great post Elizabeth.

    Well, Astatalk is on Twitter posting links for anyone to download books. So far, 931 copies have been downloaded. Please go to their Twitter page and label them as spam.

    Thank you.


  20. tia
    May 25th, 2011 at 2:37 pm · Link

    you call this “stealing” i do not, it’s the same as going to the free library checking out a book for free and returning it after its been read, down loading a book, reading it and then deleting it, is the same thing, the onle difference is you save yourself a trip to the library. the library puchases the book once maybe twice and everybody can read it, well the same goes for the internet, the book must first be purchased before it can be uploaded, why should anyone waste their gas driving to the library when they can use their internet library?

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Instagram GoodReads BookBub

Search Site

Where to now?

Privacy Policy Cookie Policy

Elizabeth Boyle is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com.
If you purchase a book listed on the site from Amazon.com, she’ll earn a small commission. Thank you!